
A Rebuttal to False Claims
MARCH 31 – WASHINGTON – The American Hospital Association (AHA) falsely claims that lifting the ban on physician-owned hospitals (POHs) would inflate healthcare costs, drain resources from community hospitals and destabilize community care. The Association’s baseless rhetoric serves only to protect its members from competition and choice for patients.
Opposition to H.R. 2191 ignores the wealth of evidence supporting the critical role that physician-led hospitals play in improving patient outcomes, increasing competition and significantly lowering costs. Blocking physician-led hospitals denies access to care for millions of Americans, particularly in rural communities.
The hospital monopoly’s lobbying group would rather deny care for rural communities with no access to hospitals for over 35 miles than allow physicians to reclaim their autonomy and deliver direct care to patients with no middlemen. Our physicians are guided by the Hippocratic Oath, not the profit-driven priorities of hospital CEOs earning exorbitant salaries of $10 million, $18 million and even $21.6 million annually.
When physicians are free to compete, patients benefit. It’s time to break the monopoly and put patients first.
Physician-Led Hospitals Provide High-Quality, Cost-Effective Care
- Contrary to AHA’s argument, research consistently shows that physician-led hospitals deliver top-tier medical care at lower costs compared to hospitals without physician ownership.
- A March 2025 study from researchers at The Johns Hopkins University found that physician-led hospitals charge 18% lower prices for outpatient procedures than other hospitals within the same markets.
- A 2023 study commissioned by the Physicians Advocacy Institute (PAI) found that physician-led hospitals would save the Medicare program over a billion dollars per year by comparing the 20 top DRGs.
- Physician-led hospitals have been shown to excel in patient outcomes, with reduced complication rates, shorter hospital stays and better mortality metrics for serious and surgical conditions. According to a 2021 Mercatus Center study, physician-led hospitals specializing in particular medical services provide statistically better care for orthopaedic and general surgical patients than comparable hospitals without physician ownership. The data demonstrate that patients do not have to choose between affordability and quality.
Physician-Led Hospitals Help Address Healthcare Deserts
- Nearly 750 rural hospitals are at risk of closure, leaving communities with little to no access to vital care. Rural areas are healthcare deserts where physician-led hospitals could be a lifeline for patients currently relying on the local EMS agency’s ambulance as their only healthcare option.
- H.R. 2191 proposes a pragmatic solution by allowing physician-led hospitals in areas where traditional hospitals have failed or where no alternative exists. Blocking this bill only perpetuates the worsening issue of care access for Americans in rural and other areas.
Efficiency and Competitive Benefits of Physician-Led Hospitals
- Physician-led hospitals are known for their ability to provide efficient, patient-centric care without the bureaucracy typically found in larger, consolidated healthcare systems. Numerous studies, including those by the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), highlight how hospital consolidation results in higher prices, reduced competition and no tangible improvements in care quality.
- By enabling physician-led hospitals to expand and serve Medicaid and Medicare patients, we not only foster competition, but also counteract the inflated pricing driven by hospital monopolies.
Repeal Unfair and Outdated Restrictions
- AHA claims that physician-led hospitals pick “the best-insured patients.” However, this ignores the fact that new physician-led hospitals are currently restricted from treating Medicare and Medicaid patients due to antiquated bans. For over 15 years, organizations like PHA have fought to allow physicians to provide care to all populations, including mothers, babies and seniors.
- Ironically, under current laws, non-physicians — including health insurance companies, churches, the government and even individuals with criminal records (“a felon can own a hospital”) — are allowed to own hospitals, while highly trained physicians are prohibited. Restricting experts trained in life-saving care from leading hospitals is not only illogical but counterproductive.
Patient-Centric Focus Over Profits
- Physician-led hospitals prioritize the critical physician-patient relationship, where decisions are driven by patient needs, not administrative bottom-line profits. The AHA’s stance against the expansion of physician-led hospitals appears focused on protecting monopolistic systems rather than prioritizing patient welfare or expanding care access where it’s most needed.
Support for H.R. 2191 Is Bi-Partisan and Evidence-Based
- H.R. 2191 has broad bipartisan support from members of Congress and endorsements from over 86 medical and payer organizations, demonstrating its importance as a systemic solution to healthcare access and quality challenges.
- Allowing physician-led hospitals to expand and compete will help reverse the impacts of healthcare consolidation, giving Americans better, more affordable options.
Current System Favors Consolidation With Higher Costs and Poor Access
- Experts, including physicians from the American Medical Association (AMA) and the American Association of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS), have warned that healthcare consolidation delivers no significant quality benefits, worsens patient experiences, contributes to physician burnout and inflates costs.
- Policies restricting physician-led hospitals are unnecessary, anticompetitive and only exacerbate these systemic issues, putting affordable healthcare out of reach for many American families.
Call to Action for Policymakers
It’s time to move beyond unsubstantiated claims and place patient interests at the forefront. Policymakers should support H.R. 2191, a forward-thinking, patient-first solution that empowers physicians to deliver the best care possible. The bipartisan support for this bill reflects its significance in addressing healthcare deserts and fostering competition to ensure timely, affordable, and high-quality care for all. We urge you to act now and support this vital legislation.
About Physician-Led Healthcare for America
Founded in 2001, Physician-Led Healthcare for America serves as the stakeholder voice for physician-led hospitals and other physician-led entities that focus on the patient-physician relationship.
Visit www.physicianled.us to learn more.